SEARCH The Web  GameSpy   GameSpy Forums  

GameSpy Forums » Legacy GameSpy Forums » [GSF] Clan Business [GSF] Initiate Approval Thread January ...
1   2   3   4   5   6   7  
Topic: [GSF] Initiate Approval Thread January 2005 (The First One Baby!!!!!)-Don't Forget To Vote!
Doctor of Phrenology
Posts: 279
Join Date: Jul '03
All of these proposals seem good to me. Except for the fact that I don't think I would have gotten in at 75%. But so long as there is no ex post facto action, I'm in favor.

 

-----signature-----
Non viribus et celeritate corporum magna gerrimus, sed sapientia et sententia et arte
-Cicero

Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History | Report Post,Report
I am the One.
Posts: 31,352
Join Date: Apr '01
In Reply To #88
Tech_Paradox posted:

In Reply To #87

I was discussing something similar with someone else... Many clans require you to actually BE active to maintain your membership. We seem to let people wander in and out and never remove them from the rolls.

Proposals:

1. Reaper the members list. Instead of people clamoring for a re-vote every N months, we institute an activity count. You must vote to remain active in the clan and you must regularly post to remain active in the clan. Miss X votes in a row (6 seems like a good number, as that's about how many initiates we have in any given month) and you're inactive. Don't post on the main board in six months and you're inactive. Spend six months on inactive status and you're out. Send an e-mail to their address registered on the clan site and PM out to all members notifying them of this - if you get no reply or it bounces, they automatically get put on inactive. For e-mail bounces, they must immediately contact Parena to get it fixed to be moved back to active. Voting in any initiation round gets you put back on active status and/or wipes your missed vote count. Inactivity due to lack of posting can only be rectified by posting - voting will not remove that strike.

2. Revamp the voting. Remove the Neutral option - you either want them in or you don't. If you want to remain neutral on someone, you don't vote (but it counts against your "Missed Vote" count). Up the required percentage to 75% so as to not have people skating in.

3. Bump the membership requirements up. Jack the required posts up to 500 and require a minimum of six months of activity on the main board, so as to keep the spammers at bay.

Any thoughts?

[Edits - tweaks to proposal 1]


This needs a new topic.

 

-----signature-----
The Turtle Moves...
Moon Base to Ground Control

Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History | Report Post,Report
parena  1051 posts
Flood Spore
Posts: 1,051
Join Date: May '02
In Reply To #90
<orange>Let's continue this in the other thread.</orange>

 

-----signature-----
------------------------------
"You don't appreciate a lot of stuff in school until you get older.
Little things like being spanked every day by a middle aged woman:
Stuff you pay good money for later in life." - Emo Philips

Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History | Report Post,Report
Private
Posts: 2,126
Join Date: Oct '01
Buttsex is cool.

 

-----signature-----
\o\o\o\o
\o\o\o\o
\o\o\o\o
\o\o\o\o
BTFzor

Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History | Report Post,Report
I am the One.
Posts: 31,352
Join Date: Apr '01
In Reply To #95

You want me, don't you.

 

-----signature-----
The Turtle Moves...
Moon Base to Ground Control

Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History | Report Post,Report
Board Guest
Posts: 2,755
Join Date: Feb '02
In Reply To #96

If he doesn't, I do.

IRT Topic

Maybe we should hold off on adding anymore people until we get things sorted out in the other topic. Thoughts?

 


Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History | Report Post,Report
Covert Agent
Posts: 8,180
Join Date: Feb '01
In Reply To #97

I quite agree.

 

-----signature-----
[P]aradox

Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History | Report Post,Report
I am the One.
Posts: 31,352
Join Date: Apr '01
In Reply To #98

Yea, maybe one of you mods could close this then, leave it stickied...maybe change the title to ' [GSF] Initiate Approval Thread January 2005-Closed To Internal Discussion'

 

-----signature-----
The Turtle Moves...
Moon Base to Ground Control

Locked Topic | Active Topic Notification | Private Message | Post History | Report Post,Report
1   2   3   4   5   6   7  
GameSpy Forums » Legacy GameSpy Forums » [GSF] Clan Business [GSF] Initiate Approval Thread January ...
© 2012 IGN Entertainment, Inc (9.02.17.2300, MEDIAPRDBOARD02) 0.031